Google
Home arrow Technology arrow Dolphin vs phpFox vs Joomla vs Drupal vs Ning vs Kickapps for Your Social Networking Site
Dolphin vs phpFox vs Joomla vs Drupal vs Ning vs Kickapps for Your Social Networking Site - Software Comparison E-mail
User Rating: / 33
PoorBest 
Written by Codernaut   
Tuesday, 24 February 2009
Article Index
Software Comparison
Price
Installation
Out of Box Functionality
Ease of Customizations
SEO
Maintenance
Frontend Look, Feel and Usability
Support
Final Grade Summary

Maintenance

Even if you buy the best car on the road, it will still require routine maintenance. The same is true with any code you buy, grab from open source, or even if it is remotely hosted. How much downtime and headaches will you experience with these software platforms and routine maintenance? All 4 of our locally hosted solutions provide an off-line mechanism which takes your site down while you perform maintenance. Taking the site off-line is a best practice and should be followed each and every time you prepare to perform maintenance on your installation.

  • Dolphin - Dolphin upgrades will probably take about 10 minutes if all goes well. You have to manually change the version number and you must update the database. If you have made any changes to the core code, you will need to use a diff program as the upgrade is simply copy new files on top of the old ones.
  • phpFox - phpFox requires uploading a copy of the entire product again and going through the installation process. If the change made to get the install to work initially bit you, prepare to get bitten a gain by the upgrade process.
  • Joomla - Joomla provides an upgrade pack as well as the full install. If you haven't made any changes to the core files, you are in for an easy time upgrading your Joomla installation. However, you have to ensure the extras you have installed are also compatible with the new version of the core Joomla you are upgrading. If they are not, the add-on will need to be upgraded as well. Many of the extensions you install in Joomla provide their own upgrade process which can be inconsistent across modules, components or plugins. So learn the extensions you install and you will need to be familiar with what it takes to upgrade them. The upgrade pack can also be used along with a diff program to perform the upgrade. We achieved great results upgrading core Joomla this way.
  • Drupal - If you have not modified the Drupal core, deleting all the core files and laying down the new upgrade files will work. The main gotcha with a Drupal upgrade is to ensure you have backed up custom files and uploads due to the fact you will delete the core. Once files are replaced, the update.php script is executed in your browser and the upgrade is complete. Learn the files and folders you should backup before upgrading and a Drupal upgrade will involve very little pain.
  • Ning - Remotely hosted solutions are maintained by the remote host, not you, the site owner. Any bugs fixes or upgrades are handled by Ning. Be sure you have some sort of backup of your site because Ning has been known to roll out new code with customers as guinea pigs.
  • Kickapps - Kickapps is generally good for fixing bugs. However, they fix the bugs without much testing and negative side effects are not uncommon! During this experiment, Kickapps rolled out a brand new version of their code right on top of us and broke vital pieces of the test site. The renamed api method calls which crippled our custom application! Luckily it was only a test site!


 

Comments  

 
0 #30 Megan 2010-02-25 13:41
This article was VERY helpful. I hired a developer to use Joomla to create my social networking site. When he came back and told me phpFox would be better for my needs, I wanted to verify that. This did it for me! Thank you.
Quote
 
 
0 #29 Renea 2010-02-15 16:05
I agree with everything in this article (except for Kickapps as I have no experience with it)

Avoid Dolphin. I admit that it looks appealing. But you don't know what you are getting until you have to get into the code. Its a nightmare.

Joomla or Drupal are the way to go in my opinion.
Quote
 
 
+1 #28 Networker 2010-02-14 12:55
Would you consider comparing Social Engine Script in this article?
http://www.socialengine.net/
I have used Dolphin, PhpFox, and played a little with drupal and Joomla. and I agree with your results on them.
HoweverI would really like your professional opinion of Social Engine Platform.
Quote
 
 
+3 #27 Sam D 2010-02-14 12:14
PHPFox is a great NO NO. Pathetic support & autocratic forum with a half-done script. Heaven for crappy modders
Quote
 
 
+5 #26 Site Visitor 2010-02-14 12:03
Don't go to phpfox, they ban people for insane and unjust reasons for silly things like moaning or expressing lite disatisfaction of the product development. The staff that run their community forums are hypocrites of their own policies and the rules don't apply to everyone... Just whomever they feel like applying them too.
Quote
 
 
0 #25 Ian 2010-02-05 21:12
How does SocialGo compare to KickApps? Anybody seriously study the two? Thank you
Quote
 
 
0 #24 dingoman11 2010-01-29 08:50
This is an excellent article. Thank You!
Quote
 
 
0 #23 Richard 2010-01-08 09:50
Boonex is a scam. If you pay 12 months hosting in advance and then you loose your debit card that the hosting was registered for renewal in TEN MONTHS TIME!
So this is 2 months in to your 12 month already paid hosting the direct debit is cancelled they then delete your whole site that has cost in building and advertising nearly $2000 est £1600 GBP ! as they are that stupid to think you would cancel hosting thats costs nothing after spending hundreds on building...SIMPLE WORD JOKERS LOOSERS...TRY CALLING THERE PHONE NUMBER IM SURE THEY RUN IT FROM MC DONALDS OR BURGER KING S PUBLIC LOO AS IT BLENDS WITH THERE SERVICE! sH17....PLEASE AVOID EVERCURRENT LIKE A ROBBER IN A SUIT ITS JUST ANOTHER BUNCH OF NO GOOD HUMAN CON ARTISTS! Boonex is a scam!
Quote
 
 
0 #22 site visitor 2009-09-10 20:55
Thank you so much for the helpful article! I will agree that Dolphin comes with it's shares of headaches and to only buy it if you are a sadomasochist.
Quote
 
 
0 #21 site visitor 2009-07-26 12:29
Anybody have good experience with abledating.com, emeeting.com, or dzoic?
Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Get New Image

< Prev

© 2010 QuantumCritics.com